I think it’s about time I talk about Sleepwalkers.
Sleepwalkers is my second feature length screenplay. I wrote it in the spring of last year for my advanced screenwriting class at the University of Pennsylvania. The goal was a romantic comedy/sci fi/drama/fantasy movie in the vein of Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind (or any other film penned by Charlie Kaufman). Far from perfect, the completion of this screenplay excited me for two reasons: one, it was based around an idea that had been stuck in my head for over a year prior to my putting it on paper and two, it was filmmable, meaning that I could, theoretically, make this movie on a budget first thing out of college.
I ended up submitting it to a screenwriting contest, the Creative World Awards. I entered my first screenplay, a sci-fi psychological thriller called Jonathan Maine, in a total of four screenwriting contests. It did relatively well in about half of them, but since these things are not cheap to enter I ended up submitting Sleepwalkers to only the contest where Jonathan Maine fared best. Jonathan Maine made it to the semi-finals of that contest before petering out. I haven’t said anything until now for fear of jinxing it, but Sleepwalkers just matched that accomplishment and, come Monday, we’ll see if it becomes a finalist.
An added advantage to the Creative World Awards is that they send you a judge’s scorecard so that you can see how you did piece by piece. There are 28 elements of your screenplay marked numerically, an average score that is used for judging, and a “pass/recommend/consider” marker that is used in real script coverages done by studios. Sleepwalkers got a “consider” and scored an 8.38 average rating (0.12 higher than Jonathan Maine’s average).
I’m crossing my fingers that I make it to the finals this year. As I said earlier, the screenplay is far from perfect. Still, it would be nice to have such an easily identifiable sign that I’m improving as a writer. Maybe my next screenplay will crack the top 10!
And now, for your consideration, some of the judge’s comments (there have been three rounds of judging so far - I only get to see comments from the first round). Plot details have been edited out due to spoilers.
BASICS: Sleepwalkers is a fascinating, imaginative fantasy-drama that plunges us into two different worlds – the ordinary world we know in our waking hours and the strange world that exists for people who sleepwalk. The story concept has great potential for a popular film or even a franchise or television series. Although there are many format problems (such as unneeded transitional devices and faulty intercuts), the Twilight Zone hook contrasts the two worlds and immediately engages the reader, and the payoff at the end is poignant and triumphal.
CHARACTERIZATION: Currently, we do not see the key characters (Ben, Allison, Amanda and Kate) as real, three-dimensional people. Ben is attracted to Amanda, a co-worker, and Allison. But we could get to know them better, their external wants, and their internal needs. Fuller development of their backstories and goals in the first half would help us empathize and go on their journeys with them.
STRUCTURE/PLOT: The story structure is sound, though the plot is somewhat narrow. Plot points are powerful, beginning with the hook, the catalyst, and the first turning point.
[ENTIRE PLOT RECAP REMOVED - SPOILERS!]
The central storyline is well constructed, and scene description is artful and imaginative, but often prosaic and interrupts the flow of dialogue. Occasional references to wishes, thoughts, or past actions cannot be filmed and could be cut. Flashbacks and flash forwards tend to confuse things a little.
A strong supporting thread or two would provide more depth, momentum, and increasing conflict across the story arc. Not least, in the rewrite, it might be good to consider holding back some of the revelation of Sleepwalkers’ world and let the reader / viewer figure it out downstream.
DIALOGUE: At times the dialogue is compelling and helps drive the story forward; at others the characters’ speech is often on the nose and includes little subtext to keep the reader guessing at meaning and underlying character traits. While we see some interesting writing tools, like voiceover and sounds bridging across scenes and settings, all the characters sound much alike.
TREND AND MARKETING: There has always been and always will be room for an engrossing romance with a unique, credible fantasy element. Such classics as Sleepless in Seattle, Memento, Deja Vous, Somewhere in Time, Ghost, Phantom of the Opera, and Twilight make the point. A well-crafted pitch for Sleepwalkers certainly would pique the interest of many filmmakers.
FINAL NOTE OF ENCOURAGEMENT: With a plot / subplot brainstorming session and a strong rewrite and polish, with empathetic, three-dimensional characters, natural dialogue, effective story threads, and efficient scene description, the final script can be a real page turner. The story concept is fascinating, with towering potential and the promise of taking us to a unique, shadowy world. For this reason, this script truly deserves consideration.
NOTE: Out of all the screenwriting contests I’ve entered, I’d say the Creative World Awards was probably my favorite, and not just because it’s the one that my scripts have done best in. Most screenwriting contests are closed book events - two of the ones I entered posted no finalist stages and jumped straight to the winners. Many offered a chance to get judge’s feedback included for insane markups - an additional $50, $100, $150… One of the other contests I entered gave me judge’s feedback that was only a page long and pretty much exclusively numerical. The Creative World Awards gives you preliminary finalists, quarter, semi and then regular finalists before announcing the winners, and most of that is done by category to make sure that you have a fair shake regardless of your choice of genre (The Matrix is never going to compete with Citizen Kane until the final round, and even then there’s a prize for best in genre). And, of course, their judge’s feedback is extraordinarily helpful, very specific, and only costs an extra $10. I’d enter this one first if you can.